Improving Health Care through Mobile Medical Devices and Sensors
From the 22 October 2013 Brookings Report
Health care access, affordability, and quality are problems all around the world and large numbers of individuals do not receive the quality care that they need. Mobile technology offers ways to help with these challenges. Through mobile health applications, sensors, medical devices, and remote patient monitoring products, there are avenues through which health care delivery can be improved. These technologies can help lower costs by facilitating the delivery of care, and connecting people to their health care providers. Applications allow both patients and providers to have access to reference materials, lab tests, and medical records using mobile devices.
Complex mobile health applications help in areas such as training for health care workers, the management of chronic disease, and monitoring of critical health indicators. They enable easy to use access to tools like calorie counters, prescription reminders, appointment notices, medical references, and physician or hospital locators. These applications empower patients and health providers proactively to address medical conditions, through near real-time monitoring and treatment, no matter the location of the patient or health provider.
In this paper, part of the Mobile Economy Project, Darrell West looks at specific applications and inventions, and discuss how mobile is transforming health care in the United States and around the world. He argues that mobile health helps frontline health workers and health care providers extend their reach and interactions – enabling them to be more efficient and effective in their provision of medical assistance. And in the conclusion, West recommends several steps that will speed the adoption of mobile technology in health care.
- Policymakers should encourage the use of mobile devices for health care. Moving to electronic systems for service delivery will save money, improve access, and provide higher levels of quality in both developed and developing nations.
- Nearly three-quarters of medical expenditures takes place on a small number of chronic illnesses including cardiovascular disease, cancer, diabetes, and asthma. We should encourage the use of mobile systems that monitor patient symptoms and provide real-time advice on treatment and medication because they have the potential to control costs, reduce errors, and improve patients’ experiences.
- We should work to remove barriers to adoption of mobile applications that aid in chronic disease management and make these tools much more widely available.
- With growing knowledge about diseases, genetics, and pharmaceutical products, the practice of medicine has become far more complicated. Health providers need access to as much accurate data as they can get on how to treat various ailments.
- One of the barriers to cost containment and quality service delivery has been the continued reliance in many locales on paper-based medical systems. In a digital world, one cannot imagine a costlier way to run a health care system.
- On the issue of government regulation, the FDA has finalized its guidance on how mobile applications and regulated mobile medical devices are to be treated in an effort to clarify some of the ambiguities and help further innovation. Having clear rules that encourage desirable behavior is the best way to move forward in mobile health.
Editor’s Note: This paper is released in tandem with the panel discussion: The Modernization of Health Care through Mobile Technology and Medical Monitoring Devices on October 22, 2013.
Related articles
- Frost & Sullivan Examines the Future of On-Demand Mobile Personal Health Records (hispanicbusiness.com)
- Mobile Health Could Save developed countries $400 billion by 2017 (nextbigfuture.com)
- The Explosion In Health Apps, And How They’re Disrupting The Gigantic, Lethargic Health Care Industry (businessinsider.com)
- Better Living Through Mobile: A Patient’s Journey (blogs.sap.com)
- Next-Gen Nanotech Breath Sensor Could Change How We Monitor Health (medgadget.com)
- Leading Healthier Lives Through Mobile Technology (blogs.sap.com)
- Patient care appears to be catching up with mobile technology (kevinmd.com)
- Better Living Through Mobile: A Patient’s Journey (business2community.com)
- Finally, FDA tells mobile health app developers what it plans to regulate [GigaOM] (gigaom.com)
- FDA To Regulate Some Mobile Health Apps (cio-today.com)
Mobile Healthcare Information For All
This is one noble cause! However, I think that education should go hand in hand with this.
It is one thing to have access to healthcare information. Another thing to understand and be able to use information.
Still, I am hoping that telecoms get on board, and give back to their communities.
Related articles
- Healthcare IT Leaders Announces Best Healthcare IT Blogs of 2013 (hispanicbusiness.com)
- Mobile Technology is Helping Us Live Longer, Healthier Lives (business2community.com)
- Mobile Apps in Healthcare Marketing 101 (business2community.com)
- Mobiles beep health messages to women in India’s villages (thehindu.com)
- Mobile Applications and the CDC (msaltaego.wordpress.com)
Curbing Malaria Spread With Cell Phone Data
From the 14 October 2012 Medical News Today article
Cell phone records may be a valuable source of data that if used correctly, could help control and eliminate malaria in sub-Saharan Africa, researchers from the USA and Kenya reported in the journal Science.
Even though malaria-carrying mosquitoes do not fly very far, the disease still manages to spread over very long distances. Infected humans can carry malaria to faraway places rapidly; as fast as a plane or car can take them. A significant percentage of infected humans have no symptoms; they can unwittingly be carrying the parasite during their travels and infecting hundreds of other people.
Humans do not infect other humans directly. An infected human may arrive to a new area and be bitten by an malaria-free mosquito. The human infects that mosquito. The mosquito, now infected, bites another person – and the disease spreads on and on…..
Malaria’s ability to spread rapidly makes it a challenging infection to eliminate, especially in parts of the world with limited resources for health care. Sub-Saharan Africa, where Malaria is endemic, is a huge area with very limited resources.
Of the one million people who die from malaria each year globally, 90% are children under five years of age in sub-Saharan Africa. Researchers from the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, University of Washington, Seattle, USA, earlier this year revealed thatmalaria incidence and mortality globally was much higher than experts had thought. The disease threatens 3 billion people around the world.
A team of researchers in Kenya has demonstrated how cell phone records may be utilized to identify regions that should be targeted in order to optimize malaria control and elimination efforts…
English: Life cycle of malaria, NIH, http://history.nih.gov/exhibits/bowman/SSmalaria.htm not very many people have lived through Malaria (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Related articles
- How Cell-Phone Data Could Slow the Spread of Malaria – MIT Technology Review (textually.org)
- Using cell phone data to curb the spread of malaria (greenerideal.com)
- Tracking Malaria With Cell Phones – ABC News (blog) (abcnews.go.com)
- Cellphones track how malaria spreads in Kenya (newscientist.com)
- You: Cell phones aid Kenya malaria study (edition.cnn.com)
- Tracking a killer: Cell phones aid pioneering malaria study in Kenya (cnn.com)
- How Cell-Phone Data Could Slow the Spread of Malaria (technologyreview.in)
Self-Tracking May Become Key Element of Personalized Medicine
Allan Bailey brought his type 2 diabetes under control for the first time by using a continuous glucose monitor.
From the 5 October 2012 article at UCSF News Center
A steady stream of new apps and devices that can be synced to ever-more sophisticated mobile phones is flowing into consumers’ hands, and this technology is revolutionizing the practice of self-tracking, in which individuals measure and collect personal data to improve their heath.
Self-trackers are using these tools to monitor sleep, food intake, exercise, blood sugar and other physiological states and behaviors. In some cases, they are using the data to identify what triggers or worsens flare-ups of chronic health disorders on their own, or with the help of an online community. In others, patients are even working together with physicians and scientists to conduct experiments, pooling their data for analysis that may shed light on the cause or best treatment for their disease.
This phenomenon was explored at a Sept. 28 symposium at Stanford University, where attendees and presenters — including two UCSF physicians — asserted not only that self-tracking can help patients to improve their lives, but also that self-tracking has the potential to change medical practice and the relationship between patients and their health care providers. The event was part of Medicine X 2012, a three-day conference on social media and information technology’s potential impact on medicine..
…
Already 60 percent of U.S. adults are tracking their weight, diet or exercise routine; one-third of adults are tracking some other indicator or symptom, such as blood sugar, blood pressure, headaches or sleep patterns; and one-third of caregivers are monitoring health indicators for loved ones, Fox said…
..
Self-tracking may not be for everyone, Abramson said, but it may be especially helpful for those who are diagnosed with medical problems for which conventional treatment typically offers little benefit; for those with symptoms and syndromes that are not adequately diagnosed through conventional medicine; for those who want to change their behavior; for those who want to identify environmental, dietary, contextual or social contributors to their symptoms; or for those who simply want to be more involved in their own health care.
Related articles
- Stanford Medicine X: Reflections on Day 1 (thebiopsy.wordpress.com)
- Bluetooth device to track blood sugar levels (thehindu.com)
- Fora Care to Unveil New Mobile App, Featuring Advanced Mobile Connectivity of FORA Diamond Series Blood Glucose Monitoring System at EASD 2012 in Berlin at Booth #3C41 (demandroid.info)
- Self-tracking may become key element of personalized medicine (medicalxpress.com)
Mobile phones: ‘Still no evidence of harm to health’ (Major safety review)
(Aside comment, wondering how many news stories I’m not getting access to because I only know English? How many great studies are in other languages..and it takes time for them (or at least their summaries) to get translated into English? Or are a large number of scientific studies that (at least potentially) have an impact on public health already already published in English?)
From the 26 April 2012 news item at BBC Health
By Jane HughesHealth correspondent, BBC News
There are 80 million mobile phones in the UKThere is still no evidence mobile phones harm human health, says a major safety review for the UK’s Health Protection Agency (HPA).
Scientists looked at hundreds of studies of mobile exposure and found no conclusive links to cancer risk, brain function or infertility.
However, they said monitoring should continue because little was known about long-term effects.
The HPA said children should still avoid excessive use of mobiles.
It is the biggest ever review of the evidence surrounding the safety of mobile phones.
There are now an estimated 80 million mobiles in the UK, and because of TV and radio broadcasting, Wi-Fi, and other technological developments, the study said exposure to low-level radio frequency fields was almost universal and continuous.
A group of experts working for the HPA looked at all significant research into the effects of low-level radio frequency…
Related (BBC) Stories
Related articles
- UK News: ‘No hard evidence’ of mobile damage (walesonline.co.uk)
- ‘Mobile Phones May Not Harm Your Health’ (news.sky.com)
- ‘No hard evidence’ of mobile damage (express.co.uk)
- National News: ‘No hard evidence’ of mobile damage (coventrytelegraph.net)
Ten Facts about Mobile Broadband
Great summary by Darrell M. West, Vice President and Director, Governance Studies at the Brookings Institution.
Here’s just one of the facts… (others topics include their outnumbering of personal computers next year, increase in overall use by Americans, job creation, reshaping of education, political engagement, public safety, and disparity reduction)
7. Mobile Helps Patients and Health Care Providers
Health care today is dominated by physicians, hospitals, the pharmaceutical industry, insurance companies, and government agencies. Patients seek to navigate their health care by moving across a variety of providers, ordering prescription drugs from pharmacies, and seeking reimbursement from either public or private insurance plans. They spend hours connecting the dots and working out the best health care for themselves and their families.
Imagine a different system where, with the aid of the Internet, electronic medical records, and smartphones, the patient is in charge.[xviii] People monitor their own weight, blood pressure, pulse, and sugar levels, and send test results via remote devices to health care providers. Patients store their medical records online and have access regardless of where they are in the United States or around the world. They get personalized feedback via e-mail and reminders when they gain weight, have an uptick on their cholesterol levels, don’t take their medicine, or have high blood pressure. Social networking sites provide discussion forums and the benefit of collective experience from other people suffering similar problems. Patients take responsibility for their routine health care and rely on physicians and hospitals for more serious medical conditions.
This system is not a futuristic vision, but is within our grasp. It would cut costs by reducing professional responsibility for routine tasks and record-keeping, while also making it possible for patients to receive higher quality care and be more satisfied with the end-result. The technologies for this kind of system transformation currently are available through cell phones, mobile broadband, remote monitoring devices, video conferencing, and the Internet.
Smartphones offer advanced features such as mobile e-mail, web browsing, and wireless communications. The sophistication of these devices has spawned a variety of new medical applications that help doctors and patients stay in touch and monitor health care needs.
For example, there is a mobile application that allows physicians to get test results on their mobile device. They can look at blood pressure records over time, see an electro-cardiogram, or monitor a fetal heart rate. AirStrip Technologies markets an application that makes it possible for obstetricians remotely to monitor the heart rates of fetuses and expecting mothers. This allows them to detect conditions that are placing either at risk.
Work by Prgomet and colleagues has found that mobile handhelds have positive impacts on hospital physician work practices and patient care. When equipped with such devices, researchers discovered benefits in terms of “rapid response, error prevention, and data management and accessibility”.[xix] These benefits were especially profound in emergency room settings where time is of the essence in treating patients.
Mobile devices offer help for developing nations. A majority of sub-Saharan Africa residents are served by cellphones with texting capabilities. A non-profit organization called Medic Mobile seeks to use text messaging in that part of the world to track epidemics and help disaster relief personnel find those in need.[xx]
These applications make doctors more efficient because they don’t have to be in the physical presence of a patient to judge his or her condition. Digital technology allows people to overcome the limitations of geography in health care and access information at a distance. This makes it possible for patients to get a second opinion by sending that person relevant medical tests. If a personal conference is required, doctors can use video conferencing to speak to patients located in another locale.
Related Resources
- Get Mobilized! An introduction to mobile resources and tools in health sciences libraries (Medical Library Association)
Archived 2011 online class including “lecture notes”, resources, class discussions, and related slides/videos
- Health Apps (in Health and Medical News and Resources selected by Janice Flahiff)
a short list of information and tracking apps derived from the above Get Mobilized class
Related articles
- From DIY Diagnostic Tests to Mobile Health Competitions (scienceroll.com)
- mHealth: Seemingly Stuck in Neutral (chilmarkresearch.com)
- mHealth Moving Fast, Raising Hope, And Questions (jflahiff.wordpress.com)
- Mobile health: Hallelujah or bah humbug? (finance.fortune.cnn.com)
- mHealth Summit 2011 – Videos Available (imianews.wordpress.com)
- mHealth Moving Fast, Raising Hope, And Questions (egmnblog.wordpress.com)
- Sensei, Inc. Presenting at mHealth Summit (prweb.com)
- Zeo Sleep Monitor CEO at the 2011 mHealth Summit (medgadget.com)
5 reasons why physicians will love mobile health
by DAVID LEE SCHER, MD in the 28 Nov 2011 edition of KevinMD.com
1. Mobile health technology will increase patient engagement. Most patients do not take the responsibility they should for their own health. They are likely preoccupied with all the stresses of everyday life and might therefore take the ‘I feel good, so I must be’ approach. They possibly mutter these words after wiping their faces, hurriedly walking out of McDonald’s for lunch. Or is it because of mistrust of their physician who they get to see for a big 15 minutes that the electronic record time slot permits? Or that they are caregivers to others and sacrifice their own well-being for that higher purpose?…
Related articles
How do you make an informed choice when downloading/selecting health apps?
Related Resources
- Top Health and Fitness iPhone Apps (by Art Writ, MD)
- mobilehealth news (an industry blog)
- [Free Webinar] What Makes a Health App Effective?
Related articles
- When is a Mobile App a Mobile Medical App? (projecthealthdesign.typepad.com)
- The Growing Hipness of Mobile Wellness (futurelab.net)
- Should Mobile Medical Apps Require FDA Approval? (informationweek.com)
- Sign of the times: Johns Hopkins shuttering its medical library (zdnet.com)
- Apple Makes Finding Medical Apps for Professional A Little Easier (jflahiff.wordpress.com)
- Health and Wellness Information and Tracking Apps (jflahiff.wordpress.com)
How Text Messages Could Change Global Healthcare
This October 24th Popular Mechanics story includes
- How text messaging is used to coordinate health care by health care professionals in rural areas across long distances
- How text messaging in Haiti was used to locate victims in search and rescue efforts despite language barriers
- Camera phones as diagnostic aids
The notion that SMS could revolutionize healthcare first entered Nesbit’s mind in 2007, when he was still a Stanford undergrad. He’d just met Dickson Mtanga, a community health worker in rural Malawi who was walking 35 miles to deliver handwritten patient charts to the nearest hospital. Nesbit biked out to Mtanga’s village one day, only to discover that his cellphone got a better signal there than it did on Stanford’s campus in Palo Alto, Calif. All those bars of service jumped from the phone’s screen and slapped him across the face: These far-reaching GSM networks, he realized, could connect doctors and patients like never before.Armed with a $5000 grant, a backpack full of old phones, and a laptop running a GSM modem and the open-source group-texting software called FrontlineSMS, Nesbit started working with the hospital and community health workers to coordinate patient care. The system they put in place allowed Mtanga and others to text in the information on those medical charts rather than making the hours-long trek. Patients could text their symptoms to doctors, cutting down on unnecessary visits for minor ailments and freeing up space for those in need of serious care. Within six months of the system going live, the number of patients being treated for tuberculosis doubled, more than 1200 hours in travel time were eliminated, and emergency services became available in the area for the first time. The operating costs in those six months: $500, Nesbit says
The explosion of cellphone use around the world has inspired a flood of new ideas about how to use that tech to improve healthcare. Besides Nesbit’s Medic Mobile, there are also ideas to turn camera phones into cheap diagnostic tools for vision problems or malaria, for example.Patty Mechael, executive director of the U.N. Foundation’s mHealth Alliance, keeps tabs on these new techs. They all face major infrastructure hurdles, such as the lack of reliable energy sources to power phone chargers in some developing countries. But another, less tangible challenge is figuring out what mobile health programs are actually working and worth scaling up, and which ones aren’t. “What we have in mHealth are millions of flowers blooming, in many ways. Lots of pilots are being done throughout the world, many of which are reaching populations of a few thousand each,” Mechael says. “We’re at a tipping point where people are starting to say, ‘Okay, we need to be a bit more strategic, collaborative, cohesive.’”
Nesbit is among the voices calling for a more focused approach to mobile health. A wave of angst washes over his face when I ask if there’s too much hype surrounding mobile health, if it’s too saturated of a field. Hype is good, he says. What’s bad is hype that’s disconnected from implementation. All the media coverage and promises made about mobile health in recent years, he says, make it seem as if millions of health workers in developing nations have already integrated their phones into their daily practice. In reality, only about 20,000 have done so. Medic Mobile has SMS systems operating in 14 countries, and that number will jump to 20 in the next six months. Only a few thousand people are using Medic Mobile’s programs today, but the nonprofit just rolled out its first SIM card application, which can be used on virtually every mobile phone in existence. By 2015, Nesbit expects to have 500,000 community health workers using SMS applications to link patients with doctors.
If he hits those numbers, ubiquity really will be the killer app.
5 Ways Your SmartPhone Can Diagnose You >>>
Read more: How Text Messages Could Be the Future of Healthcare – Popular Mechanics
Related articles
- How Your Discarded Phone Can Improve Global Health (newser.com)
- BellVoz Launches a New Communication Service, Direct SMS, Allows Customers to Send International Text Messages from their Mobile Phone, at a Lower Cost (prweb.com)
- Mobile Medicine (andrewsullivan.thedailybeast.com)
- How Mobile Phones Are Saving Lives in the Developing World (mashable.com)
10 dumb things you do at the doc’s office
From the 26 May 2011 CNN article
(CNN) — As much as she would like to, Dr. Lissa Rankin, a gynecologist, will never forget the woman who planned her wedding while lying naked on her examining table.
“Every 15 seconds, her cell phone was going off, and she was answering it!” Rankin recalls. “It was like, ‘That’s not the cake I ordered,’ and, ‘No, it’s the other gown,’ and I said to her, ‘Is this a bad time? Should I come back later?’ ”
Read the article (with the list of 10 don’ts)
Texting & public health
From the 16 August 2011 posting at Public Health–Research & Library News
According to a story in today’s New York Times, a study conducted by reaserchers from the University of Oxford and the Kenya Medical Research Institute demonstrated that texting treatment tips to healthcare workers increased the number of cases that they handled correctly and six months later, the effect was still there.
“Since each text cost less than a penny, every nurse in rural Kenya could get reminders for $39,000, the study said. That is far cheaper than sending trainers or brochures, neither of which improved care much, the authors said.”
The original report was published in The Lancet.
Related articles
- Study finds text messages help smokers quit (pakistannewsupdate.wordpress.com)
- Cellphones Boost Health Across Globe (livescience.com)